Wednesday 23 August 2017
Is that true that this narrative has been said Imam Sadiq [AS]?
ID: 507 Publish Date: 16 January 2017 - 23:20 Count Views: 339
Question & Answer » Sunni
Is that true that this narrative has been said Imam Sadiq [AS]?

و عن الإمام الخامس محمد بن علي بن الحسين الباقر ، عن عروة بن عبدالله قال: سالت أبا جعفر محمد بن علي (ع) عن حلية السيف ؟ فقال : لا بأس به، قد حلي أبوبكر الصديق سيفه ، قال : قلت : و تقول الصديق؟ فوثب وثبة، و استقبل القبلة، فقال : نعم الصديق، فمن لم يقل الصديق فلا صدق الله له قولاً في الدنيا و الآخرة

“Al-Irbili” – Kashf al-Ghumma – vol.2, p 147

Response:

Firstly: this narrative has been quoted by late “Al-Irbili” from Sunni books and it’s not found in any of Shia book;  thus we can’t accept it.

Secondly: in the document of this narrative written in “Siyar al-A’lam al-Nubala” book there is a guy named “Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Habish” {narrator} who is unknown and nothing has been said about him in Sunni books.

Thirdly: assuming that this narrative is valid, this hadith was said at the time of “Banu Umayyad” caliphate and if we take look at history of that time carefully we’ll get to answer.

Banu Umayyad” caliphate and then “Banu Abbas” were so strict towards Shias that they even ordered anyone whose name is “Ali” to be killed; as many of Sunni scholars have quoted:

كانت بنو أمية إذا سمعوا بمولود اسمه علي قتلوه

If “Banu Umayyah” heard that someone’s name is ”Ali”, they would kill him.

Ibn Hajar”- Tahzib al-Tahzib – vol. 7- p 281 /// “Al-Duhahabi” – Siyar al-A’lam al-Nubala” – vol. 5 – p 102 /// “Al-Mizzi” – Tahzib al-Kamal – vol. 20 – p 429 /// “Ibn Asakir” – the History of Damascene – vol. 41 – p 418 and ….

So, In such situation it’s quite logical that such narratives have are said to save the life of Shias and because of “Taqiyyeh” {precautionary concealment of one’s faith or opinion about something when its disclosure is feared to jeopardize one’s life or threaten any harm or loss}; on the other hand narrator of this narrative is “Urwah Ibn Abdullah”, the enemy of “Ahl al-Bayt” [AS] and the supporter of “Banu Umayyad” caliphate.

The End



Share
* Name:
* Email:
* Comment :
* Security code:
  

Latest Articles
Most Comments
Most viewed
Index | Contact us | Archive | Search | Link | List Comments | About us | RSS | Mobile | urdu | فارسی | العربیة |